Two of the best-selling Batman books ever published are on this shelf, and they were written by the same person a few years apart. That makes Jeph Loeb one of the most commercially important writers in the catalogue and one of the most divided-on: readers either treat these books as the modern Batman canon or as very handsome exercises in nostalgia.
Both positions are defensible, and knowing which camp you are in before spending is worth a few minutes.
What defines his writing
Structure borrowed from crime cinema. His Batman books are murder mysteries with a calendar: a killing a month, a shrinking list of suspects, a detective running out of time. The genre scaffolding is what gives them their shape.
Iconography over invention. He writes characters as their most recognisable versions, deliberately. The Joker is the Joker, Catwoman is Catwoman. Nothing is deconstructed, which is either refreshing or shallow depending on taste.
Written for the artist. His scripts leave enormous room for the page. Working with Tim Sale or Jim Lee, he steps back and lets images carry chapters, which is why these books look better than almost anything around them.
Emotional directness. The feelings are stated rather than implied. It is the opposite of the withholding approach in our Tom King guide, and comparing the two is the fastest way to know which kind of Batman reader you are.
The Tim Sale collection
Batman by Jeph Loeb and Tim Sale Omnibus at 1,176 pages is the book to own, and it contains The Long Halloween.
That story is a year-long murder mystery set during Batman's early career, tracking the fall of Gotham's mafia and the rise of the costumed criminals who replaced them. It is the direct source for a substantial amount of what the films have done with the character, and Tim Sale's art — angular, shadowed, closer to poster design than to conventional comic art — is half of why it endures.
The omnibus also collects the follow-ups, which means the whole partnership is in one object rather than spread over several paperbacks.
Hush
Batman: The Hush Saga Omnibus at 1,272 pages collects the other landmark, drawn by the artist covered in our Jim Lee guide.
Hush is a tour of Batman's world: nearly every major villain appears, the mystery runs the length of the book, and the drawing is as polished as mainstream superhero art gets. It is frequently the first Batman book a new reader buys, and for good reason — it explains its own universe as it goes.
The honest caveat: the mystery's solution is the most criticised element of Loeb's career, and readers who care about a fair whodunit sometimes feel cheated. The journey is the value here.
The rest of the shelf
Superman/Batman Omnibus Vol. 1 at 448 pages and Vol. 2 at 504 pages are the buddy book: the two characters narrating over each other, playing their contrast for entertainment rather than for theme.
Incredible Hulk by Loeb & McGuinness Omnibus is the Marvel work — loud, colourful and much lighter than the material in our Immortal Hulk guide, which is worth knowing if you are buying Hulk books by reputation.
Ultimate X-Men Omnibus Vol. 4 at 1,136 pages completes the shelf.
Everything is on the Jeph Loeb page.
Where to start
One recommendation: Batman by Jeph Loeb and Tim Sale Omnibus. The Long Halloween is the better book, the art is the best on the shelf, and it requires no Batman reading at all.
If you want the one with every villain in it, Hush is the more spectacular purchase and the easier gift.
Who should skip this shelf
These books are style-forward and thematically light. If you want a Batman story that argues about something — psychology, politics, the ethics of the whole enterprise — this shelf does not do that, and readers arriving from the modern prestige runs often find it thin.
The mysteries also do not entirely hold up to scrutiny. Both major books resolve on revelations that a careful reader can pick apart, and if a fair-play puzzle is what you are buying, adjust expectations before you order.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.