Nick Spencer's career contains the two extremes available to a mainstream comics writer: the most argued-about Marvel storyline of its decade, and a small comedy series about incompetent criminals that almost nobody bought and that people who did buy it will not shut up about.
Knowing which is which before you spend money is the entire purpose of this guide.
What defines his writing
The long con. He plots in reveals. Threads are planted dozens of issues ahead and the pleasure is designed to arrive when you realise what you were actually reading. It rewards omnibus format specifically, because the setup and payoff sit in the same book.
Comedy about failure. His sharpest writing is about people who are bad at their jobs. He has genuine affection for losers, and the funniest pages in his work come from characters overestimating themselves.
Politics, stated plainly. His superhero stories argue about authority, complicity and who gets believed. He does not hide it in metaphor, which is why his work provokes reactions that other writers' does not.
He will break the character. Given a choice between protecting a hero's image and telling the story he wants, he chooses the story. That has produced both his best work and his most hated.
The Spider-Man run
Amazing Spider-Man by Nick Spencer Omnibus Vol. 1 at 1,328 pages opens a long run, continued in Vol. 2 at 1,336.
He took over from the writer we cover in the Dan Slott guide and did the opposite thing: instead of changing the premise, he spent the run rebuilding it — Peter Parker's relationships, his supporting cast, the sense that this is a person with a life rather than a franchise. Where it stands against the rest of the character's shelf is set out in our ranked Spider-Man guide.
The one to buy first, and it is not the famous one
Superior Foes of Spider-Man Omnibus at 376 pages is a comedy about five fifth-rate supervillains trying to run a gang and failing at every level, told largely by an unreliable narrator who is lying to you about his own competence.
It is the best-written thing on this shelf, it is the cheapest, it is completely self-contained, and it needs no knowledge of anything. If you want to know whether this writer is for you, this is the test — and if you only ever buy one Nick Spencer book, this is the one.
Captain America: read this bit before buying
Captain America by Nick Spencer collects the run built around a reveal that made international news and that a large part of the readership rejected outright: the idea that Steve Rogers had been a covert enemy agent all along.
Two honest things about it. First, it is a serious piece of work about complicity and how institutions fall, and it is written with conviction rather than as a stunt. Second, plenty of readers found the premise unacceptable regardless of execution, and that is a legitimate position rather than a failure to understand it.
Buy it if the argument interests you. Do not buy it expecting a traditional Captain America story, because it is the opposite of one by design.
Which of these can be bought at any given moment changes constantly, so the Nick Spencer page is where to check availability rather than this article.
Where to start
One recommendation: Superior Foes of Spider-Man. Small, cheap, self-contained and the clearest demonstration of what he does well.
If you want the main-line work, go to Amazing Spider-Man Vol. 1 and read it as a restoration project after a decade of upheaval.
Who should skip this shelf
If you dislike long-form setups — if you want each volume to be satisfying on its own terms rather than to pay off two books later — his plotting will feel like waiting. And if you would rather your superhero comics stayed out of political argument, the Captain America material is not for you, and parts of the Spider-Man run will not be either.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.