Grant Morrison writes superhero comics as though the genre were a set of ideas that happen to have people in it. That produces the most rewarding shelf in this catalogue and the one most likely to be abandoned halfway, and which of those happens to you depends almost entirely on which book you buy first.
What defines their writing
The concept is the character. Their heroes are arguments about what a hero is. Batman becomes a test of whether a man can be prepared for everything; the X-Men become a question about what a species does after it stops being persecuted.
Compression instead of decompression. Where most modern writers stretch, Morrison packs. A single issue can carry what another run would spend an arc on, which makes the books dense and occasionally hard to follow on a first pass.
Sincere weirdness. The surreal material is never a joke. Doom Patrol contains a sentient street and a personified idea, played entirely straight, and the emotional stakes hold because of it.
Structures that only resolve at the end. Long runs are built as single objects with a shape you cannot see until you finish. This is why sampling one volume in the middle is the standard way readers conclude the work is incoherent.
The Batman run, and the set worth buying
Batman by Grant Morrison Omnibus Vol. 1-3 at 2,120 pages collects it as a set, which is exactly the sum of the three volumes at 672, 760 and 688 pages.
This is a seven-year single story: Batman acquires a son, is broken, is removed from the board, and comes back to a world that had to work out how to continue without him. It uses forgotten 1950s material as evidence rather than as nostalgia, which is the trick that makes it work.
The set matters more here than on most shelves, because the run genuinely does not resolve until the third volume. Buying Vol. 1 alone is buying a set-up. Our Grant Morrison Batman era guide covers the reading order inside that run in more detail.
For a Batman built the opposite way, arc by arc with a payoff each time, the Scott Snyder guide is the alternative.
The X-Men run
New X-Men by Grant Morrison Omnibus at 1,096 pages is the most self-contained major work on this shelf and the easiest recommendation.
The premise: mutants have won demographically, the school is a real school, and the threat is no longer prejudice but what a new species does with its own future. It is the run every X-Men book since has been arguing with, including the Krakoa material in the Jonathan Hickman guide.
The DC shelf
JLA by Grant Morrison Omnibus at 1,504 pages is the superhero book at its largest scale: the League as a pantheon solving impossible problems with ideas rather than force. It is the most straightforwardly enjoyable thing here.
Doom Patrol by Grant Morrison Omnibus at 1,200 pages is the strangest, and the one that made their reputation: superheroes as damaged people confronting surrealism that behaves like trauma.
The Animal Man Omnibus at 712 pages is where the metafiction starts, ending with the character meeting the person writing him. Superman by Grant Morrison Omnibus at 680 pages and Final Crisis Omnibus at 1,512 pages complete the DC side, the latter being a line-wide event with the usual caveats.
The whole shelf is on the Grant Morrison page.
Where to start
One recommendation: New X-Men by Grant Morrison Omnibus. It is a complete story in one volume, it needs no X-Men reading, and it is the clearest demonstration of the method without the commitment the Batman run demands.
If you want the major work, buy the Batman Vol. 1-3 set rather than the volumes, and read it as one book.
Who should skip this shelf
Density is the real obstacle. These books assume you will keep up, do not recap, and frequently withhold the explanation until much later. Readers who want a comic to be clear on the first pass will find the experience frustrating rather than rewarding.
The other honest warning is that emotional warmth is not the priority. Characters serve ideas, and while the ideas are extraordinary, several of these runs are more interesting to think about than to feel. If what you want is to care about people, other shelves here do that better.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.