Jason Aaron came out of independent crime comics about Alabama and Native American reservations, and the first thing you notice on his Marvel shelf is that he never adjusted his register downwards. He writes superheroes at the pitch of tall tales: gods with grudges, men who cannot die, revenge that takes centuries.
The result is a shelf with an unusually wide tonal spread. The same writer produced the most sustained modern Thor run and a Punisher book that reads like a war crime tribunal.
What defines his writing
Mythic scale, concrete detail. He writes cosmic material as though it were folklore: enormous events described in plain, physical language. It is why his Thor works where solemn versions do not.
Violence with consequences attached. His action is brutal and rarely fun. When someone is hurt in an Aaron comic the book stays with the damage.
Humour that undercuts nothing. He is genuinely funny, and the jokes sit inside serious books without deflating them. Wolverine and the X-Men is the clearest demonstration: a school comedy that never stops being about a man who is bad at being alive.
Long runs with a designed arc. His Thor is one continuous argument running for years, and the ending was planned. That is worth knowing before buying, because the volumes reward being read in order more than most.
The main run: Thor
Thor by Jason Aaron Omnibus Vol. 1 at 1,216 pages and a second volume at 1,368 pages collect the whole of it.
It opens with Gorr the God Butcher, a character built from one clean idea: a man who suffered, concluded that gods deserve to die, and got the means to do it. From there the run moves through Thor becoming unworthy, Jane Foster taking the hammer while dying of cancer, and a war that involves every god in the setting.
This is the strongest thing on the shelf and one of the best sustained superhero runs of its decade. It also demonstrates the thesis: the material is enormous, but the writing keeps it physical and sad rather than grand.
The X-Men and Wolverine shelf
Wolverine & the X-Men by Jason Aaron Omnibus at 936 pages is the school run: Logan opens a teaching institution and is comprehensively unqualified to run it. It is the funniest book on these shelves that is also about grief.
Wolverine by Jason Aaron Omnibus Vol. 1 at 688 pages and Wolverine Goes to Hell Omnibus at 984 pages are the opposite end: pulp horror, high body count, very little comfort.
The hard shelf
Punisher Max by Aaron & Dillon Omnibus at 544 pages is the most uncompromising thing he has published for Marvel, and it is genuinely unpleasant by design. Buy it knowing that.
Ghost Rider by Jason Aaron Omnibus at 536 pages and Avengers Forever by Jason Aaron Omnibus at 592 pages round out the shelf, the first as southern gothic horror, the second as a multiversal companion to his Avengers work.
The full shelf, with whatever can be bought at a given moment first, is on the Jason Aaron page. His Thor sits directly alongside the Kirby and Simonson eras covered elsewhere on the blog, and the contrast in register is the whole point.
Where to start
One recommendation: Thor by Jason Aaron Omnibus Vol. 1. It requires no prior Thor reading, the Gorr story is self-contained enough to work as a first book, and it is the clearest example of what he does well.
If you want the comedy rather than the myth, Wolverine & the X-Men is the better entry and asks slightly more familiarity with the cast.
Who should skip this shelf
The tonal range is the honest warning. A reader who arrives from Thor expecting more of the same will find Punisher Max on the same shelf, and it is not adjacent material — it is a different genre with a different purpose. And his fondness for damage means the books rarely offer relief: characters get hurt, stay hurt, and the endings tend to cost something. If you read superheroes to feel better afterwards, this is not the shelf.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.