Donny Cates has one move and he does it better than anyone: take a character everyone thinks they understand, reveal that the thing they are famous for is a symptom of something much older and much larger, and then run at it for two years.
Applied badly this is just retconning. Applied the way he does it, with genuine horror imagery and a relentless pace, it produced the most talked-about Marvel books of their period.
What defines his writing
Mythology underneath the familiar. The symbiotes are not aliens from a 1980s story, they are the offspring of a god that predates light. Thor's hammer has a history nobody told you. Every run works this way, and the reveals are engineered to reframe decades of comics at once.
Horror as the base register. He writes superhero comics as cosmic horror, with things that are wrong on a scale the characters cannot fight. That is why the art teams he works with matter so much.
Momentum over reflection. His books move. Chapters end on escalation, there is very little downtime, and the reading experience is closer to being pulled than to being invited.
Written for the long-form collection. The runs are built as continuous stories with endings, which is exactly why they read better in an omnibus than they did monthly.
The one that made his name
Venomnibus by Cates & Stegman at 1,352 pages is the essential book.
It takes Venom, a character built for the 1990s, and reveals a creation myth underneath the whole symbiote concept: a god called Knull who made darkness before the universe had light. The run is genuinely frightening in places, Ryan Stegman draws it with a density that suits the horror, and it ends where it was always going.
It also needs almost nothing from you. Forty years of Venom continuity exist, and the book explains what it needs as it goes.
King in Black Omnibus is the line-wide event that concludes it, with the usual caveat about events: many hands, many tie-ins, best read after the run rather than instead of it.
Thor and Hulk
Thor by Cates & Klein Omnibus at 1,048 pages follows the run covered in the Jason Aaron guide, and the contrast is instructive: Aaron wrote Thor as folklore, Cates writes him as a king with a problem he cannot punch. It is the more conventional of his major runs and the best-drawn.
Hulk by Donny Cates & Ryan Ottley Omnibus at 424 pages is the shortest thing on the shelf and the most single-minded: one premise, executed at speed, with Ottley drawing action at a scale that justifies the whole idea.
Availability moves constantly on a single-copy catalogue, so the Donny Cates page is the reliable place to check. Everything else we carry from Marvel is on the Marvel omnibus page.
Where to start
One recommendation: Venomnibus by Cates & Stegman. It is self-contained, it is the run that defines him, and if the cosmic-horror-under-a-familiar-character move does not work on you here it will not work anywhere else on the shelf.
If 1,352 pages is too much to gamble, Hulk by Cates & Ottley at 424 pages is the cheap test of the same instincts.
Who should skip this shelf
Two fair objections. The first is that the reveals do a lot of the work: if you dislike stories whose main event is discovering that the established version was incomplete, this shelf is built entirely out of that. The second is pace. There is very little quiet here, characters rarely get a scene that is only about them, and the emotional register stays at a shout. Readers who want interiority, or who care about the versions of these characters that existed before, will find the whole approach presumptuous.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.