This list ranks the best Superman omnibus and oversized editions by what you want out of them: one perfect book, a modern run to follow, the famous event, a shelf-filling project. If you want a single answer, start with All-Star Superman: twelve issues, no homework, and one of the most complete portraits of the character ever put on paper.
Every page count and issue list below comes from the publisher's own listing at Penguin Random House, DC's distributor, so you know exactly what each book collects before you choose.
1. Best single book: All-Star Superman
Absolute All-Star Superman (New Edition): the publisher's listing gives 328 pages collecting All-Star Superman #1-12, by Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely, in an oversized slipcase edition.
After a mission to the surface of the sun, Superman learns that his body has been pushed beyond its limits and that his time is running out. What he does with it (preparing the world for a future without him) is the whole book. Bizarro, Lex Luthor, Lois Lane and Jimmy Olsen all get their moment along the way. The same twelve issues are also collected in All Star Superman: The Deluxe Edition, also 328 pages according to the publisher.
Who it is for: readers who want one Superman book on the shelf, complete in itself, and the reader who wants to understand why the character still matters.
2. Best modern entry point: Tomasi and Gleason
Superman by Peter J. Tomasi and Patrick Gleason Omnibus: 1,128 pages. The publisher's list starts at Superman: Rebirth #1 and runs through most of Superman #1-45, plus Superman Annual #1, Superman Special #1, Action Comics #975-976 and #1000, and Super Sons #11-12.
Clark, Lois and their son Jon arrive on a new Earth and start again in a small town, while Jon learns to handle powers that keep growing. It is a superhero series built around a family, warm and accessible, and it needs no prior reading: the publisher presents it as every story from the team's run in a single hardcover.
Who it is for: new readers who want a modern run with heart, and parents looking for a Superman they can share.
3. Best reinvention: Grant Morrison's Action Comics
Superman by Grant Morrison Omnibus: 680 pages collecting Action Comics #0-18 and Action Comics Annual #1, the whole of Morrison's New 52 Superman in one volume, with art led by Rags Morales, Andy Kubert and Brad Walker.
This is Superman at the very start of his career, in jeans and a T-shirt, a blue-collar champion closer to the 1938 original than to the polished icon. Morrison then widens the story into parallel Earths and the fifth dimension. Read it after All-Star Superman and you get two very different Morrison takes on the same hero.
Who it is for: readers who like their Superman young and fast, and anyone who enjoyed Morrison's other DC work.
4. Best event: Death and Return of Superman
Death and Return of Superman Omnibus (2022 Edition): 1,408 pages collecting Superman: The Man of Steel #17-26, Superman #73-83, Adventures of Superman #496-505, Action Comics #683-692, Justice League America #69, Superman: The Legacy of Superman #1 and Green Lantern #46.
Doomsday, the fight for Metropolis, a world without Superman and his return: the whole arc, start to finish, in one book. For a display copy of the death itself, Death of Superman: Absolute Edition collects the core issues (Superman #73-75 among them) in 424 pages, which the publisher says include a gallery of more than 200 pages of artwork, essays and scripts. There is also a Death of Superman 30th Anniversary Deluxe Edition.
Who it is for: readers who want the Superman story everyone has heard of, told in full rather than just the famous fight.
5. Best long-haul project: The Triangle Era
Superman: The Triangle Era Omnibus Vol. 1-3: 4,376 pages across three books (1,376, 1,480 and 1,520 pages according to the publisher), covering the years when four monthly Superman titles told one continuous story, with a numbered triangle on each cover to show the reading order.
Vol. 1 collects Superman #49-64, Adventures of Superman #472-486, Action Comics #659-673 and Superman: The Man of Steel #1-8, and includes Clark revealing his identity to Lois. Vol. 2 builds up to and includes the Death of Superman. Vol. 3 brings the Reign of the Supermen, the debuts of Steel and the clone Superboy, the destruction of Coast City and the Hunter/Prey miniseries. Between them, Vols. 2 and 3 reprint most of the issues in the Death and Return omnibus, so pick one route or the other.
Who it is for: readers who want Superman as an ongoing world, with Metropolis, the Daily Planet and a large cast, to live inside for months.
6. Best Geoff Johns: Johns and Frank, in Absolute
Absolute Superman by Geoff Johns & Gary Frank: 664 pages with the trilogy the two made together (Superman and the Legion of Super-Heroes, Superman: Brainiac and Superman: Secret Origin), collecting Action Comics #858-863 and #866-870, Superman: Secret Origin #1-6 and stories from Action Comics Annual #10, Superman: New Krypton Special #1 and Action Comics #900, plus Gary Frank's character designs and a Johns script.
Frank's Superman is one of the most recognisable modern versions of the character, and this book gives you his three stories with Johns in DC's oversized Absolute format. The saga continues in Superman: New Krypton Saga Omnibus Vol. 1 (1,040 pages), which opens with Action Comics #866-879, so its first issues are the Brainiac story you already have here.
Who it is for: readers who buy for the art, and anyone who wants a modern classic Superman told across three connected stories.
7. Best origin story: Superman for All Seasons
Absolute Superman for All Seasons: 368 pages by Jeph Loeb and Tim Sale, collecting Superman for All Seasons #1-4, Superman/Batman #26, Superman/Batman: Secret Files #1 and the Superman story from Solo #1.
Four chapters, four seasons, and a country boy becoming Superman, told through the people around him: the Kents, Lana Lang, Lex Luthor and Lois Lane. It is the team behind Batman by Jeph Loeb and Tim Sale Omnibus, the best single book in our Batman omnibus ranking. Two other origins sit next to it: Superman: The Man of Steel by John Byrne: Absolute Edition (The Man of Steel #1-6, 328 pages), the post-Crisis reboot that set the stage for the Superman stories that followed, and Superman: Birthright The Deluxe Edition (Superman: Birthright #1-12, 304 pages), Mark Waid's twenty-first-century retelling.
Who it is for: readers who want the beginning of the story, and gift buyers looking for a self-contained Superman book.
8. Best mythic modern run: Phillip Kennedy Johnson
Superman by Phillip Kennedy Johnson Omnibus Vol. 1: 1,080 pages collecting Action Comics #1029-1049, Superman #29-32, Infinite Frontier #0, Superman and the Authority #1-4, Superman: Son of Kal-El #16-18, Action Comics 2022 Annual #1, Batman/Superman: Authority Special #1 and Superman: Warworld Apocalypse #1.
Superman leaves Earth to free Warworld, an enslaved planet with ties to Krypton, and ends up captured and forced to fight as a gladiator. It is Superman as myth and legacy, cosmic in scale, and the run continues in Vol. 2.
Who it is for: readers who already love the character and want a big, recent run with high stakes.
9. Best what-if shelf: Elseworlds
Elseworlds: Superman Omnibus Vol. 1: 1,256 pages of alternate-reality Superman stories, including Superman: Speeding Bullets, Superman: Kal, Superman: The Dark Side and Superman/Wonder Woman: Whom Gods Destroy, with writers such as David Michelinie and Tom Peyer.
What if Superman's story took a different path? From medieval kingdoms to dystopian futures, each story reshapes his origin, identity or destiny and follows the change through.
Who it is for: readers who know the classic origin and enjoy seeing it bent into new shapes.
Where to start if you are new to Superman
All-Star Superman if you want one book. Tomasi and Gleason if you want a modern run to follow. Morrison's Action Comics if you want to see Superman at the very beginning of a continuity. None of the three asks you to have read anything first.
For the full route through every era rather than a ranked shortlist, use our Superman omnibus reading guide, and the Superman page lists every Superman omnibus, Deluxe and Absolute edition we carry.
If you collect a line in order
The classic reprints work as lines of their own. Superman: The Golden Age Omnibus Vol. 1 (784 pages) goes back to Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster's original stories, from the era of Superman's 1938 debut, and Superman: The Silver Age Omnibus Vol. 1 opens the next line.
For the post-Crisis years, the omnibus editions line up closely. Later in the 1980s come Superman: Exile and Other Stories Omnibus (912 pages: Adventures of Superman #445-459, Superman #23-27, Action Comics #643-646 and Action Comics Annual #2) and Superman: Brainiac Reborn Omnibus (1,256 pages, with Superman #38-48, Adventures of Superman #461-471 and Action Comics #647-658). Triangle Era Vol. 1 then picks up the numbering on all three titles: Superman #49, Adventures of Superman #472 and Action Comics #659.
Frequently asked questions
Which Superman omnibus should I read first?
Superman by Peter J. Tomasi and Patrick Gleason Omnibus if you want a modern run, or Superman by Grant Morrison Omnibus if you want Superman's early career. If you want a single book instead, start with All-Star Superman. None of them needs any prior reading.
Is All-Star Superman collected in a big edition?
Yes, twice: Absolute All-Star Superman (New Edition), an oversized slipcase edition, and All Star Superman: The Deluxe Edition. According to the publisher, both have 328 pages and collect All-Star Superman #1-12.
Does the Death and Return of Superman Omnibus overlap with the Triangle Era omnibus?
Yes. Triangle Era Vol. 2 and Vol. 3 reprint most of the issues in the Death and Return of Superman Omnibus (Superman #73-83, Action Comics #683-692 and Superman: The Man of Steel #17-26, among others), so if you are collecting the Triangle Era you already have the event.
What is the best Superman omnibus for art?
Absolute Superman by Geoff Johns & Gary Frank, which collects Frank's three Superman stories with Johns in DC's oversized Absolute format. For a single story, Frank Quitely's All-Star Superman.
Where can I see which Superman omnibus editions are available?
Availability changes constantly, so the Superman page is the place to check: it lists every Superman omnibus, Deluxe and Absolute edition we carry.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.