This list ranks the best DC Deluxe Editions by what you want out of the book: one perfect story, the best Batman or Superman, a long project to live inside, a modern series for a newer reader. If you want a single answer, start with Watchmen: twelve issues, one complete story, and the book that changed how superhero comics are read.
Every page count and issue list below comes from the publisher's own listing at Penguin Random House, DC's distributor, so you know exactly what each book collects before you choose.
1. Best single story: Watchmen
Watchmen Deluxe Edition: by Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons. The publisher's listing says all 12 issues of the original series are collected here, with 32 bonus pages that include sketches and a new introduction by Gibbons.
An alternate 1980s America where superheroes have been outlawed, a murdered hero, and a handful of retired vigilantes (Rorschach, Nite Owl, Silk Spectre, Dr. Manhattan and Ozymandias) who discover that the killing is part of a much larger plan. It is a murder mystery, a Cold War thriller and a close look at what kind of people would put on a mask. If Moore is your writer, V for Vendetta 30th Anniversary Deluxe Edition collects V for Vendetta #1-10 with David Lloyd, including Lloyd's coloured "bridging" pages, both creators' introductions, Moore's essay "Behind the Painted Smile" and an expanded sketchbook.
Who it is for: anyone who wants one DC book on the shelf that stands completely on its own, and readers who usually prefer novels to comics.
2. Best Batman story: The Long Halloween
Batman: The Long Halloween Deluxe Edition: 416 pages by Jeph Loeb and Tim Sale, with the full 13-issue miniseries and more than 30 pages of behind-the-scenes extras, according to the publisher.
Early in Batman's career, a killer strikes only on holidays, and the Dark Knight, Jim Gordon and Harvey Dent have a year to stop him while Gotham's crime families fall apart. It is a detective story first, with almost every major villain passing through. Before it, the same team made three Halloween specials, collected in Batman: Haunted Knight Deluxe Edition (200 pages: the Scarecrow, the Mad Hatter and a Christmas Carol-style night with three ghosts). After it comes Batman: The Long Halloween Deluxe Edition, The Sequel: Dark Victory, which collects Batman: Dark Victory #1-13 and brings Robin into the story.
Who it is for: readers who want Batman as a detective, and anyone who enjoyed the noir side of the films.
3. Best Superman story: All Star Superman
All Star Superman Deluxe Edition: 328 pages collecting All-Star Superman #1-12, by Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely.
Superman learns that his time is running out and spends it on twelve impossible labours, with Lex Luthor, Lois Lane, Jimmy Olsen and the backwards Bizarro planet all along the way. Each issue works as a story of its own and the twelve add up to a full portrait of the character. The same book is also available with a variant dust jacket. For more Superman, our Superman omnibus reading guide lays out every era.
Who it is for: readers who want one Superman book, and anyone who thinks Superman is hard to make interesting.
4. Best landmark: The Dark Knight Returns
Batman: The Dark Knight Returns: The Deluxe Edition: 280 pages with the original four-issue Prestige series by Frank Miller, Klaus Janson and Lynn Varley. The publisher presents it as the 40th anniversary edition, with a new afterword by Miller and a tribute cover gallery with art by Jim Lee, Jock and others.
Ten years after Batman was last seen, Gotham has decayed and an older Bruce Wayne puts the cape back on. Gangs, television news, the Joker and a final confrontation with Superman: much of how Batman has been drawn and written since starts here.
Who it is for: readers who want to see where the modern Batman comes from, and anyone who prefers an older, harder hero.
5. Best short read: The Killing Joke
Batman: The Killing Joke Deluxe Edition: 96 pages by Alan Moore and Brian Bolland, recoloured by Bolland to present his original vision. The publisher adds stories from Batman: Black and White #4 and Countdown #31, plus Bolland's Batman and Joker covers and sketches.
The Joker sets out to prove that one bad day is all it takes to drive a sane man mad, and he picks Commissioner Gordon and Barbara Gordon to do it, while the book offers one possible origin for the Joker himself. It reads in a single sitting and stays with you much longer.
Who it is for: readers who want the Joker story everyone talks about, and anyone short on time who still wants a major book.
6. Best long-haul project: The Sandman
The Sandman: The Deluxe Edition Book One: 528 pages collecting The Sandman #1-16 and Sandman Midnight Theatre #1, by Neil Gaiman with a rotating team of artists.
Morpheus, the Lord of Dreams, breaks free after decades of captivity and sets out to rebuild his kingdom, and from there the series moves between horror, myth, history and fantasy. Five books carry the whole run: Book Two (#17-31, with Season of Mists and A Midsummer Night's Dream), Book Three (#32-50, with Brief Lives), Book Four (#51-69, with World's End) and Book Five (#70-75 plus The Dream Hunters, Endless Nights and the collected covers). Together that is 2,752 pages.
Who it is for: readers who want a long series with a real ending, and fantasy readers who have never tried a comic.
7. Best DC history in one book: The New Frontier
DC: The New Frontier: The Deluxe Edition (New Edition): 520 pages by Darwyn Cooke, collecting DC: The New Frontier #1-6 and Justice League: The New Frontier Special #1.
1950s America has outlawed its masked heroes, and Superman, Wonder Woman and Batman each work to their own agenda. Cooke tells the move from DC's Golden Age to its Silver Age as one story, with a new generation of heroes (the Flash, Green Lantern and the Martian Manhunter among them) stepping up for a threat no one can face alone.
Who it is for: readers who want the whole DC universe in one book, and anyone drawn to clean, classic art.
8. Best event: Crisis on Infinite Earths
Crisis on Infinite Earths: 35th Anniversary Deluxe Edition: 496 pages by Marv Wolfman and George Pérez, with the complete 12-issue series restored and recoloured, plus the team's follow-up History of the DC Universe and behind-the-scenes material.
The Anti-Monitor is erasing whole universes one by one, and heroes from every Earth (two Supermen, the Flash, Supergirl and many more) have to stand together. It is the event that reshaped DC's multiverse, and not everyone survives it.
Who it is for: readers who like big crossovers, and anyone who wants to understand the "before and after Crisis" that DC fans keep talking about.
9. Best modern character study: Mister Miracle
Mister Miracle: The Deluxe Edition: 376 pages collecting Mister Miracle #1-12 with bonus content, by Tom King and Mitch Gerads.
Scott Free, the escape artist, and his wife Big Barda try to keep a life on Earth while war rages between Apokolips and New Genesis and Darkseid may finally hold the Anti-Life Equation. It is a superhero war story and a marriage story at the same time, and you can follow it without knowing Jack Kirby's Fourth World. From the same writer, Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow The Deluxe Edition (272 pages, issues #1-8 with Bilquis Evely, a 2023 Hugo Award finalist) sends Kara Zor-El into space with an alien girl looking for revenge.
Who it is for: readers who want a self-contained modern series with something to say, and fans of character-driven television.
10. Best two-book saga: Jason Todd
Batman: A Death in the Family Deluxe Edition: 280 pages by Jim Starlin and Jim Aparo, collecting Batman #426-429 plus "A Lonely Place of Dying" from Batman #440-442 and The New Titans #60-61, which introduced Tim Drake as the third Robin. The publisher adds the unpublished alternate pages from Batman #428 that show what would have happened if Jason had lived.
In 1988 readers voted on whether the second Robin should die, and this is the story they decided. The answer comes years later in Batman: Under the Red Hood Deluxe Edition (544 pages, by Judd Winick with Doug Mahnke and others), where a masked vigilante, the Red Hood, arrives in Gotham with his own idea of justice.
Who it is for: readers who want Batman's family drama, read as one story across two books.
11. Best for a newer reader: Batman: White Knight
Batman: White Knight Deluxe Edition: written and drawn by Sean Murphy. The Joker is cured, takes back the name Jack Napier, wins over Gotham as a politician and sets out to prove that the city's real problem is Batman.
It needs no prior reading, it turns the hero and the villain around, and Murphy's Gotham is one of the most distinctive looks in modern Batman. The saga goes on in Batman: Curse of the White Knight Deluxe Edition (280 pages, Batman: Curse of the White Knight #1-8 and Batman: White Knight Presents Von Freeze #1), where the Joker and Azrael go after a secret in the Wayne family's past.
Who it is for: newer readers and readers coming from the films, and anyone who wants a modern Batman they can start on page one.
12. Best modern superhero run: Green Arrow by Lemire and Sorrentino
Green Arrow by Jeff Lemire and Andrea Sorrentino: The Deluxe Edition: 480 pages by Jeff Lemire and Andrea Sorrentino, collecting Green Arrow #17-34 and #23.1, Secret Origins #4 and Futures End: Green Arrow #1.
Oliver Queen is on the run from Komodo, an archer who seems better than him in every way, and the hunt leads back to the island and to what his father really did. Sorrentino's layouts make every action scene feel like a new idea.
Who it is for: readers who want a modern run in a single book, and fans of Green Arrow from television who want the comics behind him.
If you only buy one
Watchmen if you want the single best story. The Long Halloween if you want Batman. All Star Superman if you want Superman. Batman: White Knight if you are new to DC and want a modern start. None of the four asks you to have read anything first.
For Batman beyond the Deluxe line, our Batman omnibus ranking does the same job for the omnibus editions, and the Batman page lists every Batman book we carry.
Where the Absolute Universe Deluxe books fit
DC's Absolute Universe series also have their own Deluxe hardcovers, such as Absolute Batman: The Deluxe Edition Vol. 1. They are numbered volumes of ongoing series rather than complete stories, so they sit outside this ranking.
Frequently asked questions
Which DC Deluxe Edition should I read first?
Watchmen if you want one complete story, The Long Halloween if you want Batman, All Star Superman if you want Superman, and Batman: White Knight if you are new to DC. All four are self-contained.
What is a DC Deluxe Edition?
A hardcover line from DC that collects a complete story or a stretch of a run in one book. Most of the editions in this list add extras listed by the publisher, such as introductions, sketches, scripts or cover galleries. Our DC catalogue groups them with the omnibus and Absolute editions, and the guide to collected-edition formats explains the other lines.
Is The Sandman complete in the Deluxe Edition?
Yes. According to the publisher, Books One to Five collect The Sandman #1-75 in order (#1-16, #17-31, #32-50, #51-69 and #70-75), and Book Five adds The Dream Hunters and Endless Nights.
Which Batman Deluxe Editions are the best?
The Long Halloween for a detective story, The Dark Knight Returns for the landmark, The Killing Joke for the Joker, A Death in the Family with Under the Red Hood for Jason Todd, and White Knight for a modern start.
Where can I see which DC Deluxe Editions are available?
Availability changes constantly, so the Deluxe Editions page is the place to check: it lists every Deluxe edition we carry.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.